Loading...
Loading...
Quick Summary
Updated
The Blooming Book Club and Written Identity are tied at 5.0/5 in this head-to-head comparison. The Blooming Book Club has 3 member reviews and Written Identity has 4. 100% of The Blooming Book Club reviewers would recommend it, vs 100% for Written Identity. All ratings come from real member reviews. The full breakdown below should help you decide.
Updated
Written IdentityThe Blooming Book Club and Written Identity are close across ratings, reviews, and recommendations. It comes down to what matters to you. The themes and pricing above should help you decide.
Wonderful community if you like books
I love reading and being around others talking about reading recommendations and what we learned from the books we have read is great. It's always fun to exchange ideas.
Rich Gomez · Jan 31, 2026
The Blooming Book Club is a space to connect with others who enjoy reading and growing!
Emma has created a lovely corner to grab a book and dive in ~ and she values the opinions of others. She encourages us to read and then share our big takeaways! I value her ability to create a picture of a blooming garden and we are the flowers! Growing day by day! Emma is very patient and doesn't pressure us to keep up with the rigor of an in-person book club meeting. Love this community!
Melissa · Jan 23, 2026
Blooming Book Club.
Just love the energy Emma Collins puts. In this community. Always ready always there thinking for her group. I am very happy that I joined this community.
aslam Khatri · Jan 20, 2026
Such an Empowering Space!
I love being part of this community which values authenticity while also holding space for safely exploring. Frameworks encouraging personal exploration without judgement from ourselves (our worst critics) or others. Alli is funny, raw and so profound
Jill Hart · Jan 24, 2026
The Village Becomes Your Home
What I love about Written Identity, or "the village" as it is lovingly referred to, is that the founder, Alli, genuinely cares about the people in this group. She isn't looking to grow the village just so she can profit; it's about connection, the writing journey, and being able to express your feelings, no matter how ugly they may feel in the moment. The village is also special because of the amount of support. There is no competition here; only love and cheerleading. Anyone looking to rebuild from a place of sadness, depression or complete devastation will find "Written Identity" a safe place to land and start over. Zero Burnout, zero nervous system overloads here. But having said that, you don't HAVE to be sad/mad/burned out to benefit from the village. Literally anyone who just wants to write but might need prompting or reminders or someone to say "your voice is valid" will also love Written Identity. You can come as you are, and we will love the entirety of you in the village :)
Dana Skalin · Jan 24, 2026
Find Community & Yourself
From the very first prompt to now, this community has been such a beneficial place for me to learn, express and grow. Alli has created a wonderful space and environment to share that feels like a real community despite being all virtual. Written Identity has helped me to step into my purpose and stand true in my identity. Alli’s 1:1 mentorship has also helped me tremendously in my pursuit of writing professionally. Her insight and knowledge has been an asset to my growth. If you’re looking for a sense of community and an introspective approach to writing and finding your voice, this is the place to be!
allieebbarrett · Jan 23, 2026
Both have a ProveWorth Score of 5.0. It's a toss-up on paper. Read the member reviews above to see which one fits what you're looking for.
The Blooming Book Club is $10/monthly and Written Identity is free. Check the member reviews to see whether the price feels worth it for each one.
The Blooming Book Club is rated 5.0/5 across 3 reviews. Written Identity is rated 5.0/5 across 4 reviews, with members highlighting community support.
Yes. There are plenty of other self-development communities with member reviews. Browse the self-development directory for the complete ranked list.