Quick Summary
Updated
Roast & Promote π₯π’ and The Directory On Skool are tied at 5.0/5 in this head-to-head comparison. Roast & Promote π₯π’ has 2 member reviews and The Directory On Skool has 12. All ratings come from real member reviews. The full breakdown below should help you decide.
Updated
The Directory On SkoolThe Directory On Skool comes out ahead on ratings, review count, or recommendation rate. That said, Roast & Promote π₯π’ might still be the better pick depending on what you're after. The review themes above break down what each one does well.
A must-join community for Skool community builders
A must-join community for Skool community builders. Community building is hard. You face dozen decisions every day and often get stuck with indecision. Roast&Promote is a place where you can quickly get feedback on anything (about page, new offer, content, idea - pretty much anything community /business related). Moreover, Paulo will make sure you get feedback fast and high quality by tagging relevant experts under your post. An extra bonus is the vibe and the atmosphere Paulo has managed to create with the "Roasting" theme and Dragon mascot. I am enjoying being part of the Roast&Promote, just by observing how Paulo is building it. As a community builder, there is a lot to learn there. Why struggle in isolation, if you can move faster with your community business by joining Roast&Promote.
Lidia Axe Β· Jun 5, 2026
Honest Feedback That Actually Improves Your Work
I joined Pauloβs community and shared my website and Skool community for a roast. What I received was honest, constructive feedback and practical suggestions I could apply immediately. Several members took the time to point out areas that could be clearer or stronger, and many of those improvements are already implemented. What I appreciate most is that the feedback isnβt just criticismβitβs actionable. Paulo has created a space where people genuinely help each other improve their messaging, websites, and offers. If youβre willing to hear the truth and refine your work, this community can be incredibly valuable. Thank you, Paulo, for building a place where honest feedback and real support go hand in hand.
Dr. Severine Bryan Β· Mar 11, 2026
DOES WHATIT SAYD ON THE TIN
Does exactly what it says on the Tin. π I'll be honest, I came in sceptical. Skool's full of "directories" that are really just a wall of dropped links and dead threads. This isn't that. The Directory on Skool is the first one I've been in that actually understands the difference between posting and connecting. The networking games, the messaging prompts, the searchable listings, it's all built to get you seen by the right people, not just seen. I stopped shouting into the void and started having actual conversations. Part visibility hub, part networking playground, part genuine community and no awkward name badges in sight. If you're tired of promoting into silence and want your business in front of people who'll actually engage with it, get in there. Does exactly what it says on the Tin. 5 stars. βββββ
Tim Atyeo Β· Jun 7, 2026
The owner/leader of this community is personally welcoming and extremely...
The owner/leader of this community is personally welcoming and extremely responsive. This communityβs has a large amount of members and Heather still makes sure to make your experience inside feel unique. The structure of the community is genius! Incredibly easy to navigate, and engage in. I first entered this space as a buyer/looker. When I was ready to transition to being community owner myself I knew exactly where to find guidance and advice. Everyone inside here is so honest and helpful. When I was ready I upgraded to the extremely affordable premium plan and it has given my community the exposure it needed. If you are looking for a supportive community that offers affordable visibility options for your community or business, this is the one for you!! Come join us and become part of a large networking family.
Jennifer Rassbach Β· May 21, 2026
They provide a lot of positive energy and absolutely love the people who are...
They provide a lot of positive energy and absolutely love the people who are there.
Cynthia Wrench Β· May 7, 2026
Both have a ProveWorth Score of 5.0. It's a toss-up on paper. Read the member reviews above to see which one fits what you're looking for.
Roast & Promote π₯π’ is free and The Directory On Skool is free. Check the member reviews to see whether the price feels worth it for each one.
Roast & Promote π₯π’ is rated 5.0/5 across 2 reviews. The Directory On Skool is rated 5.0/5 across 12 reviews, with members highlighting networking & connections.
Yes. There are plenty of other business communities with member reviews. Browse the Business directory or check the best business communities page for the complete ranked list.