Loading...
Loading...
Quick Summary
Updated
The Five Minute Investor and The Smell of Money are tied at 5.0/5 in this head-to-head comparison. The Five Minute Investor has 7 member reviews and The Smell of Money has 4. 100% of The Five Minute Investor reviewers would recommend it, vs 100% for The Smell of Money. All ratings come from real member reviews. The full breakdown below should help you decide.
Updated
The Five Minute Investor
The Smell of MoneyThe Five Minute Investor comes out ahead on ratings, review count, or recommendation rate. That said, The Smell of Money might still be the better pick depending on what you're after. The review themes above break down what each one does well.
Really-working strategies, really very low time investment, really caring...
Really-working strategies, really very low time investment, really caring support! What else one would ask for?
Leon Rubinstein · Apr 8, 2026
Some reflections after a few weeks ...
Just reflecting on the last few weeks and what seems to be moving me forward and thought sharing might help others in the community: 1) Setting aside an hour a day - I’ve scheduled this and sticking to it has been transformative. These hours are sometimes while I go for a run, in gym, walk or trading after work when the alarms go off. 2) I’ve watched the training and some several times - each time I hear something I missed the precious times. 3) Paper trading every signal has just boosted my confidence with strategies but also building the repetitive habits and familiarity with TradingView and Interactive Brokers - I am getting quicker, accurate and more able to see errors and self correct. 4) I’ve watched all the coaching calls - listening has helped with the language, reinforcement and answers questions I have too. 5) The 90 day planning is golden - clarity and focus is power - goals are achieved one small step at a time. 6) Back testing has helped so much - confidence with preferred funds and strategies - I now know what is likely to give me the results I’m looking for. 7) Interactive Brokers is a bit daunting - aside from trading all signals in the paper account, I watched the IBKR training on their website and it has demystified the platform a bit more adding to my confidence. 8) Filling out the tracking sheet - this made a big difference to getting familiar with funds, premiums, returns, narrowing down to what fits my objectives. 9) So like how David and Beverley share their wisdom - done in a very accessible caring kind way. I do hope this helps.
Jahangir Khan · Mar 30, 2026
The Most Comprehensive Option Available
I knew David and the extent of his knowledge for almost 5 years beforehand, and I am so glad he decided to create this course. He is one of the best teachers I know, same goes for Beverley, and their joined experience with money, with life, and with planning is included in The Five Minute Investor. I have been on trading courses before, traded for years in small amounts, but this is a game changing experience. Starting with a basic strategy was so easy, with all the tools needed explained, no extra charges or fees, everything I needed was included... then the Financial Independence calculator blew my mind... I had no idea how quickly I could make such a big difference to my life, and to my husband's too, as it really does take 5 mins per day once you're all set up. Now if we wanted to, and we want to, we could both stop working in 3 years with these strategies and we are both in our early 40s! I wouldn't believe it if I hadn't done myself, as I'm sure many others won't, and I will say to you all go to the course, do the work on all the free resources and your mind will be blown just like mine. I got the cost of the course back within 3 months, and I have multiple strategies now to learn and practice, that will serve me and my family for decades. For me the priorities were: the weekly coaching sessions (being a coach myself and knowing it's very effective), security for me and my family, and the freedom of my own choices for the rest of my life. David and Beverley gave me all that, and now keep me on track by offering 90 Day Planning every quarter, which I find invaluable. I use the tools from 5 Minute Investor in others aspects of my life, introduce relatives to it, and would highly recommend it to anyone who wants to become an investor, or to find a passive income, or to retire early, or just to secure all they have and keep it safe and growing, or all the above. Thank you David and Beverley for creating this gem or financial knowledge.
Joanna T · Feb 25, 2026
Lisa makes budgeting and building wealth an adventure rather than a mundane...
Lisa makes budgeting and building wealth an adventure rather than a mundane anxiety inducing stress. Creating a place for every dollar before it hits the account is becoming a fun exercise. And to have a fun money account while building an emergency fund and paying down debt is such a fun concept! So grateful for the iDatemoney wealth accelerator program! Don't wait for a better time! Start now - no matter if you're broke, if you're financially stable, etc. It's worth the investment!
Verna Kauffman · Apr 10, 2026
A Space That Changed How I See Money
I have been in a lot of spaces that talk about money, but this community feels different because it does not just give advice, it changes the way I relate to money. This space helped me look at my numbers with more courage and that alone has been a huge shift for me. I have also seen how valuable it is to be in a room where women are not hiding from their finances, but learning how to face them and take ownership of them.
Jennylyn Pagaduan · Apr 7, 2026
This is NOT just financial strategy… and that’s exactly why it works.
This is NOT just financial strategy… and honestly, that’s exactly why it works. Lisa doesn’t just help you “manage money.” She helps you face it. For me, the biggest shift has been me no longer avoiding my debt. And that alone changed everything. I realized how much my lack of attention was actually fueling the problem. I wasn’t paying attention to what I was buying, how much it was, or even the money coming in in my favor. I was just… floating through it. Lisa doesn’t let you do that. Her approach goes deeper than numbers. The way she uses scent to anchor into the nervous system is something I’ve never experienced before. It creates this sense of calm and groundedness that makes it feel safe to actually look at your finances without having an anxiety attack or shutting down. And from there, things start to click. She helps you put into place systems that help you to clearly see what’s coming in, what’s going out with intention, and what’s been sneaking out the back door without you even realizing it. But the part I love most is that she brings the kind of tough love that doesn’t let you show up with the same excuses that have kept you stuck. Not in a harsh way… in a you’re-ready-for-more-than-this kind of way. If you’re looking for another budgeting system, this isn’t it... but if you’re ready to actually change your relationship with money and stop hiding from it… Lisa and The Smell of Money is where you start.
Heather Boers · Apr 6, 2026
Both have a ProveWorth Score of 5.0. It's a toss-up on paper. Read the member reviews above to see which one fits what you're looking for.
The Five Minute Investor is free and The Smell of Money is free. Check the member reviews to see whether the price feels worth it for each one.
The Five Minute Investor is rated 5.0/5 across 7 reviews, with members praising content quality. The Smell of Money is rated 5.0/5 across 4 reviews.
Yes. There are plenty of other business communities with member reviews. Browse the Business directory or check the best business communities page for the complete ranked list.